Kenny Evil

Member
  • Posts

    462
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Kenny Evil

  1. SFDebris covered it a few months ago and really nailed why I didn't like it. It's a bad story filled with seams of really good ideas. I also rewatched Children of Earth a few months ago and it sadly didn't hold up. There were some great moments and the ending was bleak and heartbreaking, but there was also a lot of crap and stupidity in it. That final episode though was superb, from Gwen's opening monologue to Jack's heartbreaking decision.

  2. I seem to like this episode a lot more than a lot of people. I thought it was a great send off for Smith and a great way for the eleventh to spend his life, fighting monsters and fixing toys. It'll be interesting to see if they carry on with the fairy tale angle for twelve or if they go with a new approach.

  3. tasha lem can't be river. For one thing she dies in this episode and for another this is the first time that she's meet eleven. I can see why people think she's river though given that she can fly the tardis, had been "fighting the psychopath in her all her life" and has an incredibly flirty relationship with the doctor"